Fabricio Ruch

In object-oriented programming (OOP), two key approaches for code reuse and structuring are inheritance and composition. Understanding when to use each can significantly affect the scalability, maintainability, and flexibility of your applications. In this post, we’ll explore both concepts, compare their advantages and disadvantages, and provide guidelines on when to use them.

---

What Is Inheritance?

Inheritance is a mechanism where one class (the child or subclass) inherits attributes and behaviors from another class (the parent or superclass). It allows developers to create a hierarchy of classes, promoting code reuse by enabling subclasses to use or override methods defined in their parent classes.

Example:

public class Animal
{
    public void Eat() => Console.WriteLine("This animal is eating.");
}

public class Dog : Animal
{
    public void Bark() => Console.WriteLine("The dog is barking.");
}

Here, Dog inherits the Eat method from the Animal class.

Advantages of Inheritance:

• Promotes code reuse by enabling subclasses to inherit common functionality.
• Facilitates polymorphism, allowing different subclasses to be treated as instances of a common superclass.

Disadvantages of Inheritance:

• Tight Coupling: Subclasses are tightly coupled to their parent class, making changes in the parent class potentially affect all subclasses.
• Fragile Hierarchies: Deep inheritance chains can lead to complex, error-prone code.
• Limited Flexibility: A class can only inherit from one parent (in languages like C# and Java), restricting its design options.

---

What Is Composition?

Composition involves building complex objects by combining simpler ones. Instead of inheriting behavior, a class holds references to other objects (components) and delegates tasks to them.

Example:

public class Engine
{
    public void Start() => Console.WriteLine("Engine started.");
}

public class Car
{
    private Engine _engine = new Engine();

    public void StartCar() => _engine.Start();
}

Here, Car uses an Engine object via composition to perform tasks.

Advantages of Composition:

• Flexibility: Objects can be composed in various ways, enabling dynamic behavior.
• Loose Coupling: Changes to a component class do not directly impact the classes that use it.
• Encapsulation: Each component handles its own responsibilities, leading to clearer, modular code.

Disadvantages of Composition:

• Increased Complexity: Managing multiple components can introduce additional complexity.
• Delegation Overhead: In some cases, delegating tasks to components may require more boilerplate code.

---

When to Use Inheritance

Inheritance is most appropriate when:

1. There Is a Clear „Is-a“ Relationship: Use inheritance when a subclass is a specialized version of its parent class. For example, a Car is a type of Vehicle.
2. You Need Polymorphism: If your application requires treating different types of objects (e.g., Dog and Cat) as a common type (Animal), inheritance can simplify your code.
3. Common Behavior Needs to Be Shared: If multiple subclasses share significant behavior or state, inheritance can reduce code duplication.

Avoid inheritance if:

• The relationship between classes is unclear or forced.
• You anticipate frequent changes to the parent class that may impact subclasses.
• You have a deep hierarchy that complicates code maintenance.

---

When to Use Composition

Composition is ideal when:

1. There Is a „Has-a“ Relationship: Use composition when an object is composed of multiple parts. For example, a Car has an Engine.
2. You Need Flexibility: Composition allows you to easily change components or add new ones without affecting the overall structure.
3. Encapsulation Is Important: Composition keeps components self-contained, making your code easier to understand and maintain.
4. You Want Reusable Components: By composing objects, you can reuse components in different contexts without creating complex inheritance hierarchies.

Use composition when:

• You want to minimize coupling between classes.
• You need greater control over behavior at runtime.
• You want to follow design principles such as „favor composition over inheritance.“

---

Composition vs. Inheritance: A Comparison

Feature	Inheritance	Composition
Relationship	„Is-a“ relationship	„Has-a“ or „Uses-a“ relationship
Coupling	Tightly coupled	Loosely coupled
Flexibility	Limited by inheritance chain	High; components can be easily replaced
Code Reuse	Through inheritance hierarchy	Through component delegation
Encapsulation	Less encapsulated	Stronger encapsulation
Polymorphism Support	Built-in	Achieved through interfaces

---

Real-World Example

Imagine you’re building a vehicle simulation application. You might be tempted to create a deep inheritance hierarchy like this:

• Vehicle
  • Car
  • Truck
  • Motorcycle

However, this approach can become rigid as new features are added. What if a car needs an electric engine while a truck uses a diesel engine? Instead, you could use composition to create flexible, reusable components:

• Vehicle
  • Has Engine
  • Has Transmission

With this design, you can mix and match components to create different types of vehicles without modifying the core hierarchy.

---

Conclusion

Both inheritance and composition have their place in software design. Inheritance is suitable when there is a clear „is-a“ relationship and when polymorphism is necessary. Composition, on the other hand, offers greater flexibility and encapsulation, making it the preferred choice for many modern applications.

By understanding the strengths and limitations of each approach, you can make informed decisions that lead to more maintainable and scalable software systems.